Stories

An evaluation framework for Aid for Trade project with exporting firms (en)

5 noviembre 2012
ITC Noticias

How can Aid for Trade effectively reach the poor to help their participation in global value chains? This was the subject of a regular "ideas sharing" breakfast meeting held in ITC this week. The meeting shared approaches on how to reach these beneficiaries through sectoral development programmes. Colleagues gave examples from different sectors including food security crops (Liberia), traditional commodities (coffee in Uganda) non-traditional food export crops (Kenya and Zambia), natural products (Peru) and leather products (Chad). The types of interventions include capacity building on market access and supply, providing market information and support to strengthen export linkages with buyers.

ITC's Trade and Environment Programme (TEP) funded by Denmark shared its approach to reach beneficiaries through providing targeted support to selected companies - ITC also focuses support at the policy and trade support institution levels.

The rationale for working directly with companies is the following: Companies are the direct link between smallholders and global value chain. If a programme strengthens capacity in companies, then the benefits (increased business) should accrue to employees and suppliers, notwithstanding issues relating to fair employment, gender and employment practices. For example, in 2009, the TEP worked with a coffee company in Uganda and their lead farmers to include 3,000 farmers in an organic certification scheme. This is a market-led form of intervention.

Andrew Rugariza, Good African Coffee, Uganda

Photo: Glenna Gordon/ITC

However, to know if this company orientated approach works, we need an evaluation framework criteria. The five classic evaluation criteria are: effectiveness, efficiency, relevance, impact and sustainability. Below is a table I prepared using these criteria and sketching out in the third column what this means for running a project focused on supporting companies directly. As this is the basis on which a project will be evaluated, this can help in thinking about how best to design a project that is directly working with exporting companies.

Criteria

Definition

What this means for a company orientated project

Effective

Achieve your objective

The project results in increased sales; Improved skills; Improved market access

Efficient

The outputs in relation to the inputs

The project has low management cost - e.g. relatively low spend on travel and staff

Relevance

Activity suited to the priorities of the target group

The project focuses on activities relevant to the company growing its business e.g. providing market information, contacts with buyers, training on market access requirements

Relevance

Activity suited to the priorities of the target group

The project focuses on activities relevant to the company growing its business e.g. providing market information, contacts with buyers, training on market access requirements

Impact

Positive/negative changes to group

The project leads to increased incomes of workers and smallholders

Sustainability

Will the benefits continue when project closes

The company does not rely on the project to remain operational and competitive

Back to the main page of ITC environment blog

You can also follow Alex on Twitter.